Page 6 - Flathead Beacon // 10.29.14

6 | OCTOBER 29, 2014 NEWS
Politics Rise to Fore of Race for High Court
FLATHEADBEACON.COM
READER P O L L
FLATHEADBEACON.COM
Should the Flathead County Commission Support the Water Compact?
Candidates for two open Montana Supreme Court seats adopt partisan edge, state investigates erroneous mailer
By TRISTAN SCOTT of the Beacon
Candidates in the nonpartisan race for two seats on the Mon- tana Supreme Court are caught on either side of a sharp partisan divide as one candidate’s Republican supporters fund an ad cam- paign attacking the other as a liberal activist judge.
And, with less than a week before the November election, an investigation is underway into a recent election mailer that was sent to 100,000 Montana voters, ranking the race’s four judicial candidates on various sides of a partisan spectrum.
In the race, candidate W. David Herbert is taking on sitting Su- preme Court Justice Jim Rice, and candidate Lawrence VanDyke is trying to unseat incumbent Justice Mike Wheat.
While Montana judicial elections are nonpartisan, mean- ing that candidates cannot identify with a political party – rules meant to ensure an independent judiciary – supporters of Van- Dyke have made a concerted effort to cast Wheat as a liberal activ- ist judge. VanDyke’s Republican backers have spent tens of thou- sands of dollars on ads to support that message, while Wheat and his supporters launched their own ad campaign in a race that usu- ally maintains a low profile on the ballot.
Wheat says the money battle is disturbing evidence that the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2010 Citizens United decision allowing in- creased corporate spending in federal elections has started influ- encing even the state’s bottom-of-the-ticket races, like the judi- ciary, which is supposed to be uninfluenced by politics.
Wheat is campaigning to keep the seat he was appointed to in 2010 by then-Gov. Brian Schweitzer, while VanDyke, an attorney and the former state solicitor general, has never run for elected of- fice. His website banner reads “following the law, not the politics,” and he insists he has no agenda in running for the high court other than to uphold the law.
The race had already adopted a politically charged profile and generated headlines when the erroneous mailers began arriving in voters’ mailboxes.
In addition to rating how liberal or conservative the four non- partisan candidates for Supreme Court are, the mailer – sent by researchers at Stanford University and Dartmouth College – also included the Seal of the State of Montana, suggesting that the mailer was an official voter guide sanctioned by the state.
The fliers place the candidates on a scale that ranges from “More Liberal” to “More Conservative,” represented by images of President Barack Obama and former Republican Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, respectively, at either end of the scale.
According to Stanford’s website, the mailers were sent as part of a research project.
Montana officials, along with administrators from Stanford University, launched separate investigations last week.
21% YES
TOTAL VOTES: 204
Is the U.S. Doing Enough to Combat the Spread of Ebola?
The Joseph P. Mazurek Justic Building, home of the Montana Supreme Court, in Helena. GREG LINDSTROM | FLATHEAD BEACON
The mailers also prompted U.S. Sen. Jon Tester, D-Mont., to send a letter to the presidents at both academic institutions ex- pressing his outrage.
“It is absolutely unacceptable that these institutions are using Montana elections as a political laboratory experiment, at the ex- pense of free and fair judicial elections in our state,” Tester wrote. “Your institutions may have now influenced these decisions by meddling in our elections. Perhaps that was not the intent, but nevertheless, it may well be the outcome of this endeavor. In do- ing so, it is also possible that your institutions have violated state and federal law, and I will ask appropriate authorities to fully in- vestigate this possibility.”
Montana Secretary of State Linda McCulloch has filed a com- plaint with the Commissioner of Political Practices asking the of- fice to investigate any potential wrongdoing.
A member of the Senate committee with jurisdiction over the U.S. Postal Service, Tester called for the chief postal inspector to investigate whether the two schools may have violated the Decep- tive Mailings Prevention Act.
“The integrity of our elections is what preserves our democra- cy. Efforts to undermine elections in Montana – whether by fraud or merely by poorly-designed experiments – must not be tolerat- ed,” Tester wrote. “I will do all I can to ensure that Montana vot- ers and their beliefs decide our elections, not outside influences.”
Justices Wheat and Rice have both been critical of the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2012 ruling in a Montana case that upheld the Citizens United decision, which, by endowing personhood to cor- porations, allowed them to spend unlimited money on elections.
In reaffirming its 2010 decision, the U.S. Supreme Court said that a state court was wrong to uphold Montana’s century-old ban on political spending by businesses. The ruling came as a disap- pointment to Rice and Wheat, who both wrote a brief in support of the ban.
[email protected]
79% NO
RECYCLER’S GEAR SALE
RECYCLER’S GEAR SALE
S a t u r d a y
BRING IN your used, well cared for Nordic, Tele and Alpine Touring ski gear, technical clothing, or climbing equipment (No Alpine skis) from Oct. 27th-Oct. 31st forcheckinandpricing.
Nov. 1 - sale starts at 9am
135 Main Street in historic downtown Kalispell • 406-752-2446
RECEIVE 100% STORE CREDIT
ON ITEMS SOLD!!
Save the Date! Ladies Night Nov 21st
www.rockymountainoutfitter.com
51% NO Should Kalispell Create a
49% YES
TOTAL VOTES: 126
Parking District Around Flathead High School?
62% YES
TOTAL VOTES: 93
38% NO ONLINE POLL RESULTS ARE NOT SCIENTIFIC
NORTHWEST MONTANA’S PREMIER MOUNTAIN SHOP