Page 33 - Flathead Beacon // 12.17.14

FLATHEADBEACON.COM OPINION CLOSING RANGE Dave Skinner
Equitable Division
DECEMBER 17, 2014 | 33
For the 34th year the Rotary Club of Whitefish invites you to help us help hundreds of less fortunate children right here in Whitefish to feel the Joy of Christmas.
Tax deductible donations may be paid to the Whitefish Rotary Charitable Fund, Inc. PO Box 1845, WF MT 59937
Make a child’s chRistMas Magic this yeaR
donate to the Magic of Christmas program of Whitefish Rotary.
RotaRy of Whitefish’s 34th
Magic of Christmas
Questions?
Call Bruce Aronson at 250-4248, or Bambi Goodman at 250-8421
IN 2015’S MONTANA Legislature session, one issue looks certain to cause major connip- tions, perhaps even worse than the state budget itself – the proposed Confeder- ated Salish-Kootenai Tribes (CSKT) water compact.
The tribal water issue – along with many others – has festered for over a century.
Prodded into action by federal gov- ernment litigation, Montana in 1979 created the Montana Reserved Water Rights Commission to “conclude com- pacts for the equitable division” of wa- ter rights – with the state being one side, and the feds/tribes the other. The pro- cess began in 1979, with the first com- pact (Fort Peck) approved in 1985. There was litigation as well – with CSKT be- ing early to court and slow to negotiate. Only when Brian Schweitzer became governor and appointed some new nego- tiators did the CSKT seriously sit down.
Why is the CSKT compact the last? Long story short, unlike other Montana tribes, the CSKT are a “Stevens Treaty” tribe, having signed the same boilerplate as other Northwest Indians in the 1850s. Over time, other Stevens Treaty tribes in Washington state sued, winning mind- blowing court rulings on fishing and wa- ter rights that bolster CSKT’s position.
CSKT could inflict some serious mis- ery upon all of Western Montana’s non- tribal water users – as seemed their in- tent in winter 2013.
After delaying agreement until the last possible second to dump a ridicu- lously thick document crammed full of arcane water language into legislators’ laps, CSKT took a “we’re done talking, sign this now or else” attitude.
Many off and on the reservation were shocked not only by the sheer reach of the rights claims, but also the realiza- tion the compact vacated on-reservation agricultural water rights in favor of “al- lowances.” There’s also the implications of closing the Clark Fork basin to new water rights, while unallocated water formerly thought of as available would be either owned by CSKT for sale, or for leasing at the sole discretion of the tribe.
Is that “equitable division?”
Well, the Compact negotiations oc- curred on the watch of Montana’s polit- ical-calculus master, Brian Schweitzer. Has he ever been interested in the “equi-
table division” of anything?
Equation One: Environmen-
tal groups, both wildlife and “smart- growth,” are important Democratic sup- porters. There’s no doubt Greens would like to see new water uses denied, or made really costly.
Equation Two: Indian voters are critical to Montana Democratic hopes. Period. It is in the best interest of Demo- crats to keep Indian voters happy, hope- fullyloyal.
Forget the rents CSKT will get from selling or leasing water, even the $55 million for canal re-engineering offered by the 2013 Legislature as “good faith” bargaining for a “good faith” renegotia- tion. When the Compact is settled, there will be big money forthcoming from Un- cle Sam. When Congress approved the Crow compact in 2010, the deal included $460 million in funding, $15 million be- ing Montana’s share. The Blackfeet are in line for just under $400 million in their settlement trust fund, which is not yet approved by Congress. So, I wouldn’t be surprised if more than that is on the Flathead table.
That’s a lot of happiness.
As some of you know, in June the CSKT Council paid $22,000 to a PAC founded by Kalispell state Sen. Bruce Tutvedt, for “mail-outs for the primary election.” Tutvedt told the council there was “a plan in place how to fix that 60- vote problem in the House” and “if my guys win we’re going to bring the com- pact in early in the session.”
However, the vote approving the check was only 5-4. CSKT tribal council member Carole Lankford said she was happy to “step up and take on a chal- lenge and battle that could cost us up to a billion dollars over the years. If we can do something now, why not?” But nay- voting council member Leonard Two Teeth stated, “I strongly oppose,” with opposed Patty Stevens adding “I want something to explain to the membership what we just did.”
If some council members are un- comfortable with playing PAC games in hopes of speeding compact passage and a stunning billion-dollar final bonanza, it could be they are as uncomfortable with the compact as their neighbors.
Maybe the “equitable division” is simply – division.
BOUDOIR BOUTIQUE
• bareMinerals
• Farmhouse Fresh • Clarisonics
• Ollipop
• Sweet Romance • Hanky Panky
406-755-5753
1103 South Main St. in Kalispell
Full Service Spa
Specializing in Facials & Skin Care
“THE TRIBAL WATER ISSUE – ALONG WITH MANY OTHERS – HAS FESTERED FOR OVER A CENTURY.”
Mike (Uncommon Ground) Jopek and Dave (Closing Range) Skinner often fall on op- posite sides of the fence when it comes to political and outdoor issues. Their columns alternate each week in the Flathead Beacon.
10% OFF
foundation & makeup with this coupon
$10any spa treatment OFF with this coupon
Please visit us at the
Kalispell Center Mall
during the Holiday Season!