Page 65 - Flathead Beacon // 3.25.15

FLATHEADBEACON.COM OUTDOORS OUT OF BOUNDS Rob Breeding
Neanderthal’s Best Enemy
MARCH 25, 2015 | 65
I’M INTRIGUED BY A NEW BOOK that suggests the taming and domestication of wolves gave early humans the competitive edge they needed to beat Neanderthals and win the survival game, eventually replacing those earlier hominids.
Penn State anthropologist Pat Shipman’s book, “The Invaders: How Humans and Their Dogs Drove Neanderthals to Extinction,” suggests our early ancestors in Europe got the upper hand once they’d domesticated dogs. These wolf-dogs and humans formed a perfect hunting partnership. The dogs did the leg work, running game toexhaustion,andhumansthenmoved inforthedangerousworkofthekill.The spoils were shared.
I’m usually skeptical of silver bullet theories that provide simple explanations for what are usually complex interactions between species and their environment. I suspect domesticated wolf-dogs all by themselves weren’t enough to drive Neanderthals to extinction. And one could argue our old cave cousins never really went extinct seeing as between 1 and 4 percent of the DNA of non- African modern humans comes from Neanderthals— the result of prehistoric interspecies cave trysts. But the wolf- dogs probably played a role, just as the domestication of farm animals such as cattle and pigs gave explorers from the Eurasian landmass a competitive edge when they met civilizations in other parts of the world.
We may never know for sure if dogs were the doomsday device for Neander- thals, but this isn’t just an esoteric Dis- covery Channel debate about the behav- iors of long-lost species. Whether T. rex was a hunter or scavenger for instance, is an interesting topic, but it has little impact in the modern world other than getting the underpants of feuding pale- ontologists in a bunch.
Dogs, wolves and humans, however, are still riding this rock, interacting in an evolving, complicated dance. The fury
over reintroduced wolves is disappoint- ing.I’mgladthey’reback,butit’stoobad this debate has devolved into the kind of toxic“I’mright,you’reevil,”namecall- ing that mars our political discourse.
It’s the dog domestication that inter- ests me most. Theories abound for what provoked those first wolves to edge up to our campfires forming a partnership with humans. There’s also the remark- able elasticity of the canine genome that allows for dogs as diverse as Chihuahuas and Great Danes, or the species of par- ticular interest to me, English setters.
If my early ancestors developed a competitive advantage by domesticating wolves, allowing our species to eventually rule the planet, I’d say I’m still reaping benefits from the partnership. Sure, plenty of folk live their lives without owning a dog, but I have to wonder about them just a bit.
The dog’s edge is its remarkable ability to read and understand humans. The interaction and cooperation my dog Doll provides is remarkable, especially given the limited level of training I provided to turn her into a hunter. She has the advantage of 400 years of selective breeding on her side, but as an educator I can tell you that getting youngsters of our own species to follow even the simplest of instructions can seem an impossible task.
And with students I share a “mostly” common language.
Doll and I don’t converse, verbally at least. But a day hunting is still a long conversation between human and dog. Her body language is as definitive as any words.
Conversely, I’ve been able to com- municate to Doll that I prefer she point, rather than flush, birds once she finds them. This was the trickiest part of her training, as I also learned by watching her that she took great pleasure wander- ing off in the distance, nosing birds into the air. The occasional treat of a crunchy bird head helped her along her journey.
The spoils, it seems, are still shared between human and dog.
CABINETRY TO FIT ANY LIFESTYLE AND EVERY BUDGET!
Come visit our showroom and see our selection of quality, affordable cabinetry. Our designers are ready to show you the new colors and styles to fit your budget and make your dream kitchen come true. Experience the difference of custom, frameless, inset and framed cabinetry.
CABINET HARDWARE Emtek® • Amerock® • Berenson®
KALISPELL
41 WEST RESERVE DR 406.752.9696 HOURS:
M–F 7:30AM–5PM
LAMINATE
Formica • Wilsonart • Nevamar®
www.probuild.com
REELECT
ALAN RUBY
FOR FLATHEAD ELECTRIC COOP
• Trustee
• Proven Leadership and Community Commitment
• Keeps Members Interests FIRST
LAKESIDE
TOWN
CENTER
PROFESSIONAL SPACE AVAILABLE
IN BUSTLING LAKESIDE MARKET
DAVID FETVEIT
BROKER
406.249.1764