Former Quarterback Rape Trial Begins with Jury Selection

By Beacon Staff

MISSOULA — More than 150 potential jurors packed a hotel ballroom Friday for the rape trial of a former University of Montana quarterback, as attorneys attempted to seat an impartial panel in a town where Griz football is king.

Jury selection in the trial of Jordan Johnson took place at the Holiday Inn after District Judge Karen Townsend said no courtroom was large enough to hold the massive jury pool.

The high-profile case is set against a backdrop of NCAA and federal investigations of how the school and the city of Missoula respond to rape allegations on campus.

The situation has left some worried that the Grizzlies football program — while successful on the field — was out of control off it.

The rape accusation against Johnson, 20, has created a buzz across Missoula, a town that centers on the university, and in a state where UM football is the top sports attraction.

Only two people among the first 39 seated in the jury box raised their hands when Assistant Attorney General Joel Thompson asked who hadn’t heard about the case against Johnson.

“Does anybody feel like they’re just too big a Griz fan to be on this case?” Thompson then asked.

Nobody raised a hand. But later, one juror was dismissed after saying she had been following the case since Day 1, is a big Griz fan and had already formed an opinion that she couldn’t set aside.

Johnson is accused of raping an acquaintance while they watched a movie at her residence last year. Johnson says the sex was consensual.

On the eve of the trial, former U.S. Rep. Pat Williams, who is now on the board that oversees Montana’s university system, said UM is recruiting “thugs” for its football team.

The Democrat made his comments in a Thursday New York Times story, then repeated them in an interview with Missoula radio station KGVO-AM. He said there have been too many UM athletes convicted or suspended over rapes, assaults or burglaries during the past year.

Williams said he was not speaking about Johnson.

“We need a better recruiting system because the current recruiting system is letting in too many thugs. And that has to stop,” Williams told the station. “As a member of the board of regents, I intend to do what I can to make sure that this very limited thuggery stops.”

The board of regents distanced itself from the comments, saying Williams was speaking for himself.

“We as a board do not agree with the statements made,” Chairwoman Angela McLean said in a statement.

A prosecutor’s affidavit said Johnson and the alleged victim had known each other since 2010 and decided to watch a movie at her house on Feb. 4, 2012.

The woman told investigators Johnson held her down and forced her to have sex with him in her room despite her protests.

Court records show the woman texted her roommate: “Omg … I think I might have just gotten raped ….he kept pushing and pushing and I said no but he wouldn’t listen … I just wanna cry … Omg what do I do!”

Johnson, in a motion to dismiss the case, said the woman had flirted with him the night before at a party and consented to sex the next night, even asking if he had a condom.

Thompson, the prosecutor, asked potential jurors whether they believe a man is less likely to commit rape if he has ready access to consensual sex, and whether they believe women falsely accuse men of rape.

He angered one man when he asked if he was “confident your daughter would never falsely accuse someone of rape?”

The potential juror said the question was intrusive.

It was defense attorney David Paoli’s turn to question the jury pool late in the afternoon. He stressed to the potential jurors that proving guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt” is a heavy burden.

Jury selection was to resume Monday morning, with opening arguments to follow.

Last April, the federal Department of Education announced it was investigating a complaint alleging the university discriminated against female students, faculty and staff by failing to address a sexually hostile environmental caused by its failure to appropriately respond to reports of sexual assault.

Soon after that, the U.S. Justice Department announced its investigation into the handling of rape investigations and prosecutions, and the school announced in May the NCAA had been investigating its athletic programs for undisclosed reasons.

The Department of Education said this week it had closed the discrimination complaint because the allegations were being addressed by the Department of Justice investigation. The Justice Department and NCAA investigations continue.

An outside investigator found nine alleged rapes or sexual assaults involving students had occurred between September 2010 and December 2011, including at least two that hadn’t been reported.

In one case, former Montana football player Beau Donaldson pleaded guilty to rape and was sentenced to 10 years in prison.

Stay Connected with the Daily Roundup.

Sign up for our newsletter and get the best of the Beacon delivered every day to your inbox.