Attorney General to Defend Cap on Court Awards

By Beacon Staff

HELENA — Montana’s attorney general intends to defend the state’s limit on the punitive damages that can be awarded to an individual by a judge or jury.

The attorney general’s office filed notice with the Montana Supreme Court on Tuesday that Tim Fox will intervene in a constitutional challenge of the $10 million punitive-damage cap.

District Judge Kurt Krueger of Butte previously ruled the cap is not a large enough deterrent for a big company. The ruling came in a case in which a jury awarded a $52 million judgment against Comerica Inc. for reneging on a 2008 agreement with a Butte-based office supply company.

The company, Masters Group International Inc., is asking the Supreme Court to uphold Krueger’s ruling that the state law setting the cap is unconstitutional.

Stay Connected with the Daily Roundup.

Sign up for our newsletter and get the best of the Beacon delivered every day to your inbox.