BILLINGS — A Montana judge will decide if a suspect’s alleged confession to his involvement in the slaying of a woman jogging through her town in the Bakken oil patch should be suppressed because the defendant is mentally disabled.
District Judge Richard Simonton on Thursday scheduled an Oct. 1 hearing in Sidney in the case of 25-year-old defendant Michael Keith Spell of Parachute, Colorado.
Spell is accused of killing 43-year-old Sherry Arnold during an attempted abduction. The high school teacher and mother of two disappeared while jogging in Sidney in January 2012. Her body was found more than two months later in North Dakota.
A second defendant, Lester Van Waters Jr., also of Parachute, has pleaded guilty to deliberate homicide by accountability in a deal with prosecutors. In a separate Thursday order, Simonton said Spell’s defense team will be allowed to depose Waters in the lead-up to Spell’s Nov. 17 trial.
Richland County prosecutors dropped their pursuit of the death penalty for Spell after experts testified he is mildly mental disabled.
Spell allegedly confessed to his involvement in the crime six days after Arnold disappeared, during an interrogation by FBI agents in the hours following his arrest by a SWAT team in South Dakota.
Prosecutors have said there is no reason to throw out Spell’s statements because they were lawfully obtained.
But the defense says Spell was not mentally capable of waiving his rights to remain silent and have an attorney present for the FBI interview. Spell’s attorneys want his statements — and any evidence obtained as a result — barred.
“Mr. Spell is young (22 years old at the time of the interrogation), intellectually disabled, and based on his two most recent IQ scores, he has the mental age of about 11,” defense attorneys Al Avignone and Lisa Banick wrote. “Mr. Spell believed the FBI agents were his friends, and he was simply helping them solve the disappearance and murder of Mrs. Arnold.”
The defense has not disputed that Spell was involved in the events leading up to Arnold’s disappearance, but contends there’s no definitive proof he killed her.
Spell told the agents he and Waters had arrived in Sidney looking for work in the Bakken oil fields along the Montana-North Dakota border, according to excerpts of Spell’s interrogation cited by prosecutors. After smoking large amounts of crack cocaine, Waters said he wanted to kidnap and kill a woman.
After the first woman they hoped to target, at a public laundry, left before they could carry out their plan, Spell said the pair saw Arnold. Spell said he grabbed her and dragged her back to their vehicle, where Waters killed her, according to court documents.
Waters has implicated Spell as the killer.
Prosecutors said the FBI agents repeatedly sought to make sure Spell knew what was going on during his interrogation.
“Intellectual disability, while relevant, must be assessed in the totality of the circumstances,” Deputy County Attorney T.R. Halvorson wrote. “Otherwise, we would be punishing the police simply because of the defendant’s condition even though they have done nothing wrong.”
An expert for the defense, Boise, Idaho-based clinical psychologist Craig Beaver, is expected to testify at the Oct. 1 hearing.
Stay Connected with the Daily Roundup.
Sign up for our newsletter and get the best of the Beacon delivered every day to your inbox.