Court: No Public Defender Unless Jail Time is at Stake

The Montana Supreme Court ruled 5-0 on case from Cascade County

By Associated Press

HELENA — The Montana Supreme Court says a judge can’t order a public defender to represent a criminal defendant if no jail time is at stake.

The court ruled 5-0 on Wednesday that Cascade County Justice of the Peace Steven Fagenstrom doesn’t have the authority to compel the Montana Office of the State Public Defender to represent a defendant who was charged with misdemeanor theft of $650 in August.

The maximum penalty for first-offense theft of property not exceeding $1,500 is a $500 fine without the potential for jail time.

Fagenstrom argued that a state law barring the agency from representing indigent offenders when incarceration isn’t a possible punishment is unconstitutional.

The high court ruled that the Sixth Amendment does not guarantee the right to counsel at public expense for such misdemeanor offenses.

Stay Connected with the Daily Roundup.

Sign up for our newsletter and get the best of the Beacon delivered every day to your inbox.