HELENA – Six members of the Montana Supreme Court will consider a legal challenge to a new Montana law that would eliminate the state’s judicial nomination commission and allow the governor to appoint judges to fill vacancies between elections, the court ruled Wednesday.
Republican Gov. Greg Gianforte signed the bill on March 16 and a legal challenge was filed asking the Montana Supreme Court for an injunction to block the law from taking effect and to declare it unconstitutional.
Montana’s 1972 Constitution states that Supreme Court and District Court judges must be elected, with the exception of vacancies where “the governor shall appoint a replacement from nominees selected in the manner provided by law.”
The legal challenge was filed by Bob Brown and Dorothy Bradley, lawmakers who voted to create the Judicial Nomination Commission during the 1973 Legislature; 1972 Constitutional Convention delegate Mae Nan Ellingson; Vernon Finley, a former chair of the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes’ Tribal Council; and the League of Women Voters.
Chief Justice Mike McGrath recused himself from the case on March 24 without explanation. His appointed replacement, District Judge Kurt Krueger, recused himself because he had participated in a Montana Judges Association poll on the legislation.
Attorney General Austin Knudsen asked for the results of the judges poll, which the order states was 34-3 against the bill. None of the Supreme Court justices participated in the poll, the order states.
Gianforte was given until April 14 to file the state’s response to the motion, in part because the Legislature wants to pass a resolution so it can file a motion to intervene.
The Judicial Nomination Commission is made up of four people appointed by the governor, two appointed by the Montana Supreme Court and one elected by the District Court judges. The commission interviews people who apply for judgeships and forwards three to five names to the governor, who must chose from among those nominees.
Opponents of the bill to eliminate the nomination commission expressed concern that having the governor appoint judges to fill vacancies between elections would inject politics into the the process.
The state Senate has yet to consider measures to confirm three District Court judges who were appointed by former Democratic Gov. Steve Bullock.
Hearings were held in the Senate Judiciary Committee in late March, but the committee has not voted on the nominations. There was no indication during those hearings that Gianforte opposed their nominations.
If the Senate rejected their nominations, the new law could allow Gianforte to appoint replacements.
Stay Connected with the Daily Roundup.
Sign up for our newsletter and get the best of the Beacon delivered every day to your inbox.