Guest Column

Elections Have Consequences

We have a Legislature chock full of clueless anti-regulation, anti-government, and anti-wildlife zealots

By Brian Peck

Decades ago, while listening to Flathead radio star George Ostrom, I heard him say, “Well, the Montana Legislature is in session, and for the next 90 days no man’s life or property are safe.” The 2021 Republicans in the Legislature, in total control for the first time in 16 years, and with a Republican governor to boot, seemed intent on proving George right on a daily basis. Let us take a look at their descent into lunacy:

Like many outdoor recreation communities, Whitefish has been having trouble providing affordable housing for employees with modest incomes. So, Whitefish passed a law requiring developers to have a certain percent of units be affordable housing. Although they claim to love “local control,” Republicans killed that fast because it would place undue burdens on developers. The bill was introduced by a developer.

As the pandemic raged, several county health boards passed mask mandates and limits on gathering size to control disease spread. Once more, Republicans “deep-sixed” this local control, giving the authority to all those medical experts on county commissions. What could possibly go wrong by removing health boards during a pandemic, and putting anti-science know nothings in charge?

On the wildlife front, Republicans were intent on doubling down on blatantly anti-conservation, anti-science assaults on wolves and grizzlies.

Wolves: HB 225 adds a month to the wolf trapping season and prohibits closing areas next to national parks. Who does not favor killing national park wolves? HB 224 allows snaring (strangulation) of wolves – or dogs, bears, your kids. SB 267 authorizes reimbursement for wolf killing – a bounty – right out of 1850. SB 314 would reduce wolves to “sustainable levels;” allow unlimited killing on one license; baiting and night hunting of wolves with lights or night scopes. I am sure no deer or elk poachers will take advantage of that. These measures could kill more than 900 wolves and guarantee their relisting as a threatened species.

These measures were passed on behalf of wolf haters and trappers, although Montana’s 5,000 trappers have negligible economic impact, while Yellowstone wolves alone bring in more than $35.5 million annually to the regional economy.

Grizzlies: HB 468 allows hound hunting and chase in spring season for black bears to train dogs. So, how do you tell the dogs not to chase protected grizzlies, or females with cubs of the year? SB 337 says Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks can respond to grizzlies “causing conflict outside of a federal recovery zone” but cannot relocate the bear – translation – more dead grizzlies. SB 98 says that grizzlies “seen threatening livestock” can be killed. What rancher seeing a grizzly in the same zip code does not think it is threatening their livestock? This regulation violates federal law and guarantees grizzlies can never be delisted from the Endangered Species Act because there will be “inadequate regulatory mechanisms” to protect them.

How does nonsense like this find its way into law? Simple. In the last election a significant majority of Montanans went to the polls, voted for everyone with an “R” after their name and voila we get a Legislature chock full of clueless anti-regulation, anti-government, and anti-wildlife zealots. If you are one of those voters, you are as much to blame as the Legislative Loons who passed it. Your actions and elections have consequences. You might want to think about that, and what you have caused before the 2022 elections roll around. 

Brian Peck lives in Columbia Falls.

Stay Connected with the Daily Roundup.

Sign up for our newsletter and get the best of the Beacon delivered every day to your inbox.