Greetings, Beacon Nation! Hell hath no fury like the attendees of a Whitefish fireworks spectacle scorned.
Although Saturday night’s display at Whitefish City Beach began approximately 40 minutes earlier than scheduled, disappointing scores of spectators who strained to see the spectacle as the sun still hung over the horizon — not to mention those who missed the show altogether — the ensuing public outcry was right on time.
“We are from Indiana and saw that your show was touted as being ranked in the top 10 best firework shows and honestly, that was more likely to be ranked in the top 10 worst ones,” a commenter from the Hoosier state posted to the Whitefish Chamber of Commerce’s Facebook mea culpa. “As my husband commented on another post, ‘I’ve seen better firework displays in people’s backyards.'”
Dang. Hope you brought your burn cream, Whitefish.
Okay, okay. So, maybe this year’s fireworks display won’t garner any five-star Yelp reviews, and that’s fine; after all, user-generated online content is protected speech under the First Amendment, and further evidence of the freedom we the people just spent our weekends trolling er … celebrating.
Still, one might assume that locals have grown accustomed to the city’s storied tradition of Independence Day mishaps. Perhaps they’ve even come to appreciate the small-town idiosyncrasies that have caused so many of our July Fourth bashes to backfire.
One would be wrong.
Keep reading for a brief history of why Whitefish’s Fourth of July fails live on in infamy.
I’m Tristan Scott, here to light up your inboxes, and lighten up your moods, with this Monday edition of the Daily Roundup.
Presented by the Whitefish Chamber of Commerce and coordinated by the City of Whitefish’s Parks and Recreation Department, the community’s July Fourth celebrations are objectively breathtaking. Punctuated by Big Mountain, the Whitefish Range’s ragged skyline provides the backdrop to a fireworks show that’s launched from a barge 100 yards off the eastern shore of Whitefish Lake. In addition to the crowds at City Beach, hundreds of boats converge on the lake to watch from their sun decks in a gorgeous display of community.
I still remember the first time I criss-cross applesauced onto a picnic blanket at City Beach and marveled at the grand spectacle, my eyes spinning like pinwheels as the extravaganza ensorcelled throngs of local spectators and out-of-town visitors alike.
And while I’m grateful for those good years, gratitude alone doesn’t mitigate a pattern of fireworks fiascos, ranging from random misfortunes meted out by Mother Nature to this year’s apparent lapse in pyrotechnic prowess, all of which have conspired to characterize the city’s Independence Day celebrations on a handful of occasions.
Among the annals of July Fourth displays that disappointed rather than dazzled are repeat instances of burning barges, swamped firing systems, capsized cadmium caches, events canceled due to wildfire danger, and, now, premature ignition.
I understand the public’s disappointment. Families engineered their entire evenings around the spectacle, braving gridlock traffic and parking lots brimming with boat trailers to secure a postage stamp of lakeside real estate. Floaters paddled furiously upriver to reach City Beach in time for the magic hour. Tourists traveled here after learning about Whitefish’s vaunted July Fourth fireworks display in listicles published by esteemed national outlets such as the New York Times. Our own quarterly lifestyle magazine, Flathead Living, features a cover photo of a pair of paddleboarders silhouetted in electric-pink iridescence from fireworks festivities of yesteryear.
But some of the comments online seemed aimed at fomenting more than merely healthy discourse among an informed citizenry. Matter of fact, they made the Boston Tea Party seem like a game of pick-up sticks. And yet, I found the Chamber’s response measured and reasonable, even if it left readers wanting for specifics.
“The early launch,” according to the Chamber’s social media post, “was the result of a combination of miscommunication, operator error, and an unexpected technology malfunction.”
“The Whitefish Chamber sincerely apologizes to everyone who was still en route to City Beach, those on the beach who experienced the show in brighter conditions than intended, and our generous sponsors who helped make this cherished community event possible,” the post continued. The early launch was the result of a combination of miscommunication, operator error, and an unexpected technology malfunction. As the Air Force helicopter was clearing the area, the pyrotechnic crew activated the computerized system. They were quickly informed, however the launch could not be deactivated, resulting in the fireworks starting ahead of schedule.
“We understand many people were disappointed, and we sincerely regret that the evening did not unfold as planned. We will be conducting a thorough debrief with everyone involved to better understand what occurred and to implement measures that help prevent this from happening in the future.”
Each year, according to the Chamber, it relies on the generous support from the community to fund the show, as well as its attendant logistics such as insurance, shuttles, promotion, and more, with the costs exceeding $20,000. The event is not supported through taxpayer dollars, as some online commenters suggested, and which the Chamber was eager to debunk
“Finally, we want to assure our community that no government funds were used for this year’s fireworks display. This event has always been made possible through the generosity of local businesses, sponsors, and civic-minded residents. We are incredibly grateful for their continued support,” according to the Chamber’s post. “Thank you to everyone who joined us at City Beach to celebrate Independence Day. Despite this unfortunate error, it was wonderful to see our community come together to enjoy a beautiful Montana evening and celebrate America’s 250th anniversary.”
Here’s the rest of your Monday edition of the Daily Roundup.
Through the Glacier Range Riders' host family program, the Flathead Valley's Coopman family has built lifelong connections with baseball players from across the country
Bull Trout Spawning Study Could Aid in Recovery of Imperiled Swan River Basin Population
Chemical analysis of ear bones reveals which tributaries bull trout originate in, helping biologists identify streams and habitat critical to the species' future
Whether you’ve been here for decades, or you’re new to the Flathead Valley, our reporting is here to help you feel smarter and in the loop about the issues most important to Northwest Montana. With your support, we can build a more engaged, informed community.